Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill Menu (Update 2025)
Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill in Sarasota, FL, is a seafood lover's paradise. With a variety of fresh seafood options like crab cakes, grouper salads, snapper dishes, and shrimp skewers, it's easy to see why customers rave about the quality of the food. The key lime pie is a must-try dessert, hailed as the best in Florida by satisfied diners. The casual atmosphere, knowledgeable staff, and excellent service add to the overall dining experience. The restaurant also offers a good wine list, beer selection, and non-alcoholic choices. Whether you're in the mood for a simple fish sandwich or a more elaborate seafood dish, Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill delivers on taste and freshness. Visit this hidden gem for a no-frills seafood experience that will leave you craving more.
From the Start
Stone Crab
October th May th. Enjoy a Florida classic caught by Captain Rich, a friend of Fresh Catch. Served with mustard sauce or drawn butter
Smoked Fish Spread
Mahi fish spread, served with vegetable sticks and Ciabatta crostini
Devon's Lump Crab Cake
Maryland Blue Lump Crab, served with a house made Remoulade sauce. No filler here!
Royal Red Shrimp Cocktail
Served with cocktail sauce and lemon
Ahi Tuna
Seared, pepper crusted Ahi, served with watermelon salsa, refreshing, give it a try!
Oysters On The Half Shell
Available in - doz/doz. Oysters hand shucked to order, served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce
Bob's Baked Oysters
One dozen oysters baked w/ butter, oregano, Parmesan, Romano and fresh parsley
Shrimp Peel & Eat
White Florida Gulf Shrimp served hot. Your choice: Plain, Old Bay or Garlic Butter ($.), Loaded ($.)
Clams
Middle Neck Clams steamed with onion and celery, served w/Ciabatta crostini
PEI Mussels
PEI Mussels steamed with onion, celery, tomato, garlic, served w/Ciabatta crostini
Devon's Fisherman Stew
Homemade fish stew, tomato based with carrots, celery and onion
New England Style Clam Chowder
Lobster Bisque
Soups
From the Garden
Fresh Catch Salad
Mixed greens, chopped tomato, cucumber, sunflower seeds with a citrus vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, fresh Parmesan cheese, cracked pepper with a creamy Caesar dressing
Dinner Salad
Side Salad
Traditional Steam Pot
Shrimp, clams, Snow or Dungeness crab, corn on the cob, baby potatoes
Snow Crab Or Dungeness Crab Pot
Crab Pots served with corn on the cob and baby potatoes
Red Alaskan King Crab
Crab Pots served with corn on the cob and baby potatoes
From the Steamer
From the Grill
Fresh Catch Fish Sandwich
Your choice of fish fresh from our case, grilled or blackened served with lettuce, tomato on a Brioche bun
Happy Snapper Wrap
Grilled Snapper with tropical salsa, mixed greens, cucumber, and aioli sauce wrapped in a flour tortilla
Fresh Catch Tacos
Your choice of Grouper, Mahi Mahi or shrimp on a soft tortilla with homemade coleslaw, aioli sauce, and choice of tropical salsa or Pico de Gallo
Crabby BLT Sandwich
Maryland Blue lump crab cake, bacon, lettuce and tomato on a Brioche bun
Brisket Burger
Burger served with lettuce, tomato on a Brioche bun
Fresh Fish Plate
Your choice of fresh fish from our case, blackened or grilled, topped with: Lemon & Butter, Pico de Gallo or Tropical Salsa
Royal Red Shrimp Skewer
Shell-on Argentinean Royal Red shrimp, Blackened or grilled with lemon & butter
Devon's Lump Crab Cakes
Two Maryland Blue lump crab cakes, none of that filler
Plates
To the End
Mom's Key Lime Pie
Freshly made each morning, served with homemade whipped cream on the side